UK watchdog bans Shell, Repsol and Petronas greenwashing ads

The UK’s promoting watchdog has banned a gaggle of massive oil and fuel firm ads for being deceptive as a part of crackdown on “greenwashing”, or making one thing seem extra sustainable than it truly is. 

The Promoting Requirements Authority stated on Wednesday that latest adverts by Shell, Repsol and Petronas had misled the general public on the local weather and environmental advantages of the teams’ merchandise total.

The landmark rulings are anticipated to set a precedent for a way vitality firms promote their companies.

The banned adverts included a tv promotion for Petronas, a web based advert for Repsol and poster, TV and YouTube adverts for Shell. These adverts had “omitted materials info” by selling their “inexperienced” presents and plans, akin to renewable vitality and web zero objectives, with none point out of their bigger polluting operations, and as such had been “deceptive”, the ASA stated. 

Within the rulings, the ASA identified that polluting merchandise nonetheless dominated the companies of the three firms involved.

The banned Shell advert selling its inexperienced credentials with out point out of its bigger polluting operations. The oil group ‘strongly disagreed’ with the ASA’s determination © Shell

“Massive-scale oil and fuel funding and extraction comprised the overwhelming majority of [Shell’s] enterprise mannequin in 2022 and would proceed to take action within the close to future”, but the adverts in query gave the alternative impression, the regulator stated.

Repsol, in the meantime, “had a considerable oil and fuel exploration technique”, and the biofuels and artificial fuels it had promoted in adverts this yr amounted to “a fraction of [its] enterprise actions when in comparison with [its] substantial, ongoing, and increasing fossil gas manufacturing”, the ASA stated.

Equally, the general public wouldn’t perceive the “extent of Petronas’ persevering with important contribution to greenhouse fuel emissions given the presentation and claims” in a 2022 advert, the regulator added.

Veronica Wignall, from the Adfree Cities marketing campaign group, which led the criticism towards Shell, stated the ban “marks the top of the road for fossil- gas greenwashing within the UK. The world’s largest polluters won’t be permitted to promote that they’re ‘inexperienced’ whereas they construct new pipelines, refineries and rigs.” 

Shell stated it “strongly disagreed” with the ASA’s determination. Customers had been “nicely conscious that Shell produces the oil and fuel they rely upon” however won’t know that it was additionally investing in “low and zero-carbon vitality”, the corporate stated.

Repsol stated it had allotted a couple of third of its “whole funding to low-carbon companies at some point of its 2021-2025 strategic plan”, including that it was dedicated to a simply vitality transition”. Petronas declined to remark.

The sanctions come as a part of the UK regulator’s wider probe right into a collection of environmental claims throughout industries together with heating and transport.

The regulator has this yr cracked down on airways Etihad Airways and Lufthansa for deceptive claims in regards to the environmental influence of flying, whereas final yr it banned adverts by HSBC that it judged to have misrepresented the financial institution’s inexperienced credentials, and one other by Tesco about its plant-based merchandise.

The ASA can also be drawing up guidelines to control carbon neutrality and web zero claims extra broadly.

Regulators within the UK, EU and US that police promoting, competitors and monetary markets are turning extra of their consideration to climate-related disclosures. 

Authorized and local weather consultants count on the heightened scrutiny to translate right into a rising variety of authorized instances to problem probably deceptive claims or breaches of fiduciary duties. 

Caroline Lucas, a Inexperienced get together MP, stated greenwashing adverts had been “allowed to disseminate faux fossil-fuel information for a lot too lengthy”. The federal government ought to give the regulator better powers to allow it to “proactively . . . reject these completely deceptive adverts” and ban all “high-carbon promoting”, she added.

Extra reporting by Tom Wilson

Local weather Capital

The place local weather change meets enterprise, markets and politics. Discover the FT’s protection right here.

Are you interested by the FT’s environmental sustainability commitments? Discover out extra about our science-based targets right here

Back To Top